Report: NYC ‘raided’ $200M from MTA to balance budget

SHARE NOW

(The Center Square) – New York City budget writers “raided” $200 million in public transit funds to help reduce the city’s revenue shortfalls, according to a new report by a fiscal watchdog.

The analysis by Reinvent Albany revealed that the state budget, signed by Gov. Kathy Hochul in June, authorized New York City to make a one-time $200 million reduction in annual operating support for Metropolitan Transportation Authority bus service, a cost that many observers expected would be picked up by the state government with surplus revenue.

“Unfortunately, the state has quietly chosen not to compensate MTA bus service, leaving the MTA – and ultimately bus riders – to eat the loss of City funding,” the group wrote in its report.

The report said the scope of the cash raid is commensurate with what New York City transit riders, including MTA buses and subways and the Staten Island Railway, are expected to pay in fare increases in 2027 and 2028.

In May, Hochul and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced that they had reached a deal to provide the city with funding to close an estimated $4 billion budget gap. The deal came in response to Mamdani’s threat to increase property taxes instead.

“However, nowhere in the state budget bills or supporting documentation was there mention of the city’s MTA payments being forgiven or deferred as part of the package,” Reinvent Albany said in the report. “Indeed, the announcement made it sound like the state was providing aid – that the $4 billion was ‘new state assistance’ to the city.”

Historical budget records show a 2004 agreement between New York City and the MTA requires the city to pay the gap between bus costs and fares and revenue from its operations. The report said the city’s “backdoor raid” will worsen the MTA’s massive out-year budget deficits, which are expected to reach $897 million by 2030, according to the transit agency’s estimates.

A Hochul spokesperson said the MTA’s funding reduction has had “zero impact” on New Yorkers’ bus service and said the governor has no plans to backfill it with surplus revenue.

“No governor has stepped up to support the MTA and its riders like Governor Hochul,” the spokesperson said in a statement made available to The Center Square. “She saved the agency from a fiscal cliff and has made historic investments to improve and expand service.”

But transit advocates criticized Hochul and state leaders for leaving MTA riders holding the bag for what amounts to a cut in funding for city bus service.

“Raiding public transit funds or trying to balance the city budget on riders’ backs makes New York less affordable and erodes trust in our government,” Betsy Plum, executive director of the Riders Alliance, said in a statement made available to The Center Square. “When just last month MTA agents assaulted a bus rider over $3, it’s clear the transit system needs the money and must be made whole.”

The MTA’s board of directors is expected to discuss the agency’s deficits at Wednesday’s regular meeting, when an updated financial plan for the month will be released.