‘Untenable’: Critics blast $17B Interstate Bridge over single bidder, funding gaps

SHARE NOW

(The Center Square) – The Joint Oregon-Washington Legislative Action Committee charged with oversight for the Interstate Bridge Replacement Program, held a virtual work session on Monday, with critics asking key questions as the project advances toward construction.

As with prior meetings, the briefing highlighted ongoing challenges related to a lack of contractor competition, funding gaps and a design that includes light rail and funding for Oregon’s financially troubled TriMet system that some critics say amounts to a taxpayer bailout.

“You have only a single bidder for this project. That puts you in an untenable bargaining position,” said Portland Economist and IBR project critic Joe Cortright during public testimony Monday.

The main Columbia River Bridge Replacement contract is valued between $3.3 billion and $3.9 billion, and Kiewit is competing through a joint venture called Columbia River Constructors, which also includes Guy F. Atkinson Construction and Traylor Bros. Inc.

Critics have noted that Columbia River Constructors was the only team to submit qualifications for the project’s primary bridge contract, with a formal proposal due by March 24, 2027.

Oregon’s and Washington’s transportation departments are expected to make a final selection by May 2027, and construction would begin on the new bridge sometime in 2028.

Phased funding, not secured

Program administrators have outlined a two-stage plan, through funding from Washington and Oregon, as well as federal funding $5.69 billion for Stage One, while leaving a $1.41 billion gap for Stage 2 for a project that has current cost estimates reaching $13 to $17 billion.

“If the feds pony up all they’ve been asked, which is $3.1 billion in the plan, that means the two states have to find that $8 billion plus,” said Rep. John Ley, R-Vancouver, in a Tuesday interview with The Center Square. “That means both states have to come up with $4 billion.”

Ley said he doesn’t understand why other lawmakers, regardless of political affiliation, haven’t voiced their objection to the IBR project sucking the life out of transportation funding dollars.

“If I’m a rep from Spokane, or if I’m a rep from anywhere in the Puget Sound that needs roads, bridges, or if you’re looking at the Washington ferry system, they’d be screaming, ‘Are you out of your mind?"”

Ley said funding for any other project will require more tax increases.

“And what does a local representative get if they vote yes to raise a gas tax, or a card tab fee, so that the government gets more money, and none of it is coming to [their] district,” Ley said.

Other critics at the Monday meeting testified that the design fails to expand highway capacity and questioned the inclusion of light rail and tolling which is expected to be implemented in 2028 on the I-5.

Gary Clark with Neighbors for a Better Crossing noted in a Nov. 1 Op-Ed, “To those who have followed the IBR and its predecessor, the Columbia River Crossing (CRC), it looks far more like a $15-17 billion administrative toll and tax levy imposed on Oregon and Washington residents without meaningful taxpayer oversight, voter approval, or clear public benefit.”

Clark’s article noted that for years, the IBR insisted the project would cost only $4-6 billion.

Only after an independent Oregon journalist forced the issue in 2025 did officials concede the range had climbed to $13-17 billion.

The article said cost overruns could easily push the total past $30 billion.

As previously reported by The Center Square, a lawsuit has been filed to halt the project.

Iron Partners LLC, the plaintiff, contends that the Federal Highway Administration and related agencies did not follow proper environmental and navigation laws, and the company is asking the court for an injunction to stop current construction plans for the project.

Project officials with IBR provided a response via email to The Center Square’s request for comment after that article about the lawsuit.

“The Interstate Bridge Replacement Program cannot comment on active litigation. Currently the suit has been filed against the IBR Program’s federal lead agencies with the Federal Highway Administration and Federal Transit Administration,” the email said.

The email directed The Center Square to contact the Oregon and Washington FHWA division administrators for further comment.

The Center Square contacted via email FHWA Oregon Division Administrator Keith Lynch and FHWA Washington Division Administrator Brian Hasselbach for comment, but did not receive a response before publication.

As reported by The Center Square, during a Sept. 17 meeting, Rep. Ed Orcutt, R-Kalama, urged the IBR oversight committee to listen to public concerns from people who don’t feel like their voices have been heard.

“I personally believe that we need a new bridge, but I don’t think we need light rail and the people in Clark County have spoken that quite clearly that they do not want light rail and feel like they have not been listened to,” said Orcutt.

“I think we need to change our focus of this advisory committee to actually be an advisory committee and not one that just continually accepts progress reports from DOT.”

The Joint Oregon-Washington Legislative Action Committee charged with oversight for the Interstate Bridge Replacement Program is not scheduled to meet again in public session until June 2027 at the earliest.

Ley told The Center Square that although he won’t be part of the committee anymore, given his reelection bid was not successful, he intends to stay involved.

“I’m not going anywhere and will certainly be a part of this fight,” he said.