NYC Council approves surveillance pricing ban

SHARE NOW

(The Center Square) – The New York City Council has passed a ban on the use of surveillance pricing despite opposition from retailers and industry groups.

Legislation approved Thursday will outlaw the practice of using shoppers’ personal data to charge different customers different prices. It would give the New York Department of Consumer and Worker Protection the authority to investigate complaints and issue fines of up to $1,000 per violation, with each consumer or transaction counted as a separate violation.

“The City Council is putting consumers first by ending the deceptive and insidious practice of surveillance pricing,” Council Speaker Julie Menin said in a statement ahead of Thursday’s vote. “When corporations use algorithms and personal data to charge different people different prices for the same products, it’s unethical and worsens our affordability crisis.”

The bill, if signed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani, would also allow small businesses to avoid fines if violations are promptly addressed through a formal appeal process. The bill also allows retailers to still use discounts and rewards if they are “legitimate and transparent” such as buy-one-get-one-free deals and loyalty programs to discounts for veterans and students.

Councilor Harvey Epstein, who chairs the Council’s Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, said surveillance pricing has become “yet another tactic for major corporations to leverage technology to ratchet up the cost of everyday goods for New Yorkers.”

“And when pricing is based on personal and biometric data, which is exactly what surveillance pricing relies on, the probability of discrimination skyrockets,” he said Thursday.

Mamdani said Thursday supported the Council’s push to prohibit surveillance pricing, calling another way for corporations “to squeeze working people.”

“New Yorkers’ personal data should never be used as a weapon against their own pocketbooks,” the democratic socialist said in a statement. “Our administration will continue working with the Council to protect workers, tenants and consumers, and put an end to the scam economy.”

Business and industry groups have panned the proposal, saying it would erode consumer savings by eliminating so-called loyalty deals, digital coupons, and personalized discounts that reduce prices for goods.

The effort to ban the practice is backed by New York Attorney General Letitia James, a Democrat who has pushed for approval of state restrictions on algorithmic pricing as part of her consumer protection agenda.

A proposal pending action by Gov. Kathy Hochul would authorize the AG’s office to pursue civil cases for penalties and restitution against retailers that use surveillance pricing. It doesn’t include an option for appeals.

The One Fair Price Package would set a statewide ban on big-box stores, retailers and grocery stores from using shoppers’ personal data to charge different customers different prices, among other provisions. Hochul is being pressured by both supporters and opponents to sign or veto the legislation before the end of the year.